Minutes of Track 2.II
Documenting a movement: Lesbian Archives and Collections
Wednesday 26 August 1998
Six speakers talked about their experiences working in lesbian archives, from the initial set up to ongoing consolidation and expansion. Issues discussed include involvement in community activism, how the information is gathered, who does and should use the archive, and how information is disseminated.
Brigitte Geiger, STICHWORT, The Archives of the Women's and the Lesbians' Movement
in Vienna, Austria
STICHWORT was founded in the early 80s, in the context of growing and diversifying
feminist movements and the first attempts to organize feminist scholars in Austria. It is
maintained by an independent foundation, but receives subsidies from the state and
communities. It is a collective staffed by volunteers and paid workers. They run a library
and a documentation centre which collect published and unpublished materials of all kinds,
from all media. Brigitte focused on 3 major aspects one has to deal with when documenting
a social movement: The problem of defining and constructing -an archivist has to decide
where to obtain information, STICHWORT requires evidence of autonomy and political
intention, as well as some material product to add to the archive. Problems of acquisition
and collection - building up collections on a social movement's activities and
representatives needs constant and active information policies. STICHWORT receives a lot
of information from leaflets and circulars etc from other participants in the women's
movement but actively seeks detailed procedural information from other institutions. It is
important to raise consciousness and make people realise the value of this kind of
information. They feel it is especially important to decide the future of archives, so the
information will be protected even if the library is closed. Problems of dissemination and
usage - Feminist archives are not mere historical places, they contain information centres
and help build information networks. STICHWORT encourages research, and also active use of
the materials collected, while respecting the difference between public and private.
Adele Patrick, Glasgow Women's Library, Scotland
The library was started as a grass roots initiative in 1991 growing from the liberal
women's movement. It is currently the only women's library in Scotland, and since its
beginning it has expanded considerably, taking in a separate lesbian archive from London
in 1995 that would otherwise have been thrown away. The lesbian archive is stored in a
women only space, separate from the women's collection, although they do share resources.
Since the archive has moved to Scotland, it has gained information about lesbian life in
Scotland. In part this is because all materials are donated, though it is true to say that
all collections reflect the politics of the users. Should we keep these politics alive, by
storing information in the original format, or can we update storage systems? The library
receives no revenue funding, but has done successful fundraising, as well as collecting an
annually renewable membership fee. The more successful the fundraising, the more
successful they have been in getting grants. The library aims to make itself invaluable to
the local council, by undertaking paid research work, this should enable its continued
existence.
Question How do you feel about m/f transgender people using a women only lesbian
space? Glasgow - This issue is problematic, currently we only accept women born women
lesbians only, but we need advice on how to develop a fair policy. Finland - Lesbian and
gay movement includes transgender and transsexual people, we are mutually supportive and
feel the need to band together because we are so few. New York - This is a huge issue, our
volunteer policy is 'If you think you're a woman, you're in', but we are not a women only
space. We include trans-gendered people, but this is problematic for some older lesbians
who don't like trans-gendered people seeing lesbian materials. Other groups, please can
you tell us if you have a policy, or a women only space.
Olga Jans, Lesbian Archives Nijmegen, The Netherlands
The lesbian archives in Nijmegen opened in 1995 after being inspired by the Lesbian
Herstory Archives in New York. They share premises with the lesbian and gay centre, and
other gay an lesbian organisations. Their aims are to collect, store and disseminate
lesbians' information and gay materials of interest to women, and to increase lesbian
visibility. The collection contains books, and other published and unpublished material
from all media - their specialisation is diversity, but they began with a regional focus.
Books and videos can be rented, but other material is stored to protect it. Finance comes
from fundraising and donations, but the rent and costs are paid by local government. The
users are lesbians, grass root interest groups, students, researchers, therapy groups and
the media. They lobby to maintain their position. They have formed a network with other
women's information centres in Europe. This gives support and information, but also uses
up time and resources. Changes in the women's movement, and social trends mean that they
have to prioritise constantly, this is exhausting, but gives inspiration and new impulses.
Ivana Cikes, Because Press, Croatia
Because Press was set up in September 1997, and aims to publish and promote material with
a lesbian content that would not otherwise be available in Croatia. They use the printed
word to open communication channels among the lesbian community, hoping to lead to change
in the restrictive social realities of post-war Croatia. Since the onset of the war,
women's and men's roles have been clearly defined by the ruling party, strongly supported
by the catholic church. Acceptable behaviour for women is to raise children and support
family values; men should be aggressive and controlling. The ruling party has strong
control, is able to shut down independent radio and journalism, thus silencing alternative
voices. The stance on homosexuality is explicit 'Since the beginning, mankind was
accompanied by homosexuality. It was always here whether we admit it or not. From the
humanistic point of view, it is better to admit it and to make it as invisible as
possible'. Lesbians are portrayed as being ill, deviant, or just going through a phase, so
many hide their lesbian identity. In Zagreb there is some freedom because the city at
least offers safety in numbers, but even to call yourself a feminist can lead to abuse and
harassment. The women's movement was first seen in the former Yugoslavia in 1979, but in
1986 the first radical feminist group was set up, in comparatively liberal political
times, but with the change of ruling party in 1990, the 2nd wave of feminism came to an
end. Since then new women's information centres have been established, but even within the
one openly gay and lesbian group, lesbian issues were not on the agenda, so in autumn 1997
the Croatian lesbian scene organised itself as its own entity, to address its own problems
and issues. A lesbian social support group and phone line has been set up, though the
founder has suffered from harassment. Because Press wishes to achieve more tolerance and
freedom of expression for lesbian women. Obviously books cannot achieve this alone, but
publication indicates a change within the lesbian community, and allows women access to
information.
Ivana wants to discuss how a group like ours can expand and take advantage of external
resources, while being self supporting and supporting our members.
Olga Stefaniuk, OLA archiwum, Poland
The Polish Lesbian Archive was established in Warsaw, in 1996. Its activities include:
Gathering books, magazines, papers and other documents on lesbian and feminist movements
in Poland and abroad Conducting historical and archival research in collaboration with
other lesbian archives abroad. Lesbian studies discussion meetings. Publication of a
lesbian literary journal.
The idea to establish this archive came from Berlin in 1984. Olga lived there for 2 years
and saw lesbian archives, thought it would be easy to gather information, set up her
archive and discovered it isn't so! It is theoretically legal to be lesbian in Poland, but
the word 'lesbian' is taboo, and often not known, and it is socially unacceptable to be
lesbian. The OLA archive collects women's literature in sociological and women's studies
fields. Much of the material is donated, thanks to German, French and other presses; other
international archives offer moral support. There are hardly any gay and lesbian groups in
Poland, so OLA does everything - it is an information centre, library, documentation
service etc. There are lots of Polish articles on the women's movements, but they are very
heterosexual in focus, so Olga's publication is a reaction against that and is a bridge
between the beginnings of a lesbian movement in Poland, and the movement in the rest of
the world. It is important to encourage Polish lesbians and now they can speak about
lesbianism with each other, and the rest of the world, for the first time. There is
difficulty in discourse because of a lack of Polish terminology, and this creates problems
with translated materials so it is important to gather existing Polish materials to fill
this gap. It is vital to have contact with other international lesbian archives; we need
to improve the exchange of ideas, and then move on to actions.
Proposal: to set up a lesbian archive conference in Warsaw, achieved through mutual
support and co-operation.
Answer: We have to keep in touch, set up a listserv, and try to arrange a
conference of some kind for lesbian archivists.
Karen Martin, Gay and Lesbian Archives of South Africa, (GALA)
GALA was established in January 1997, enabled to do so by recent political liberation. It
shares a building with the South African Historical Archive. One of GALA's main areas of
research is lesbian and gay involvement in the anti-apartheid struggle, so they can liase
with SAHA and share resources. This affiliation is advantageous to GALA because they are
on university premises, which gives them status and helps to make gay an lesbian history
more mainstream, though it also takes away some independence. Although they have collected
lots of material, the lesbian voice is hard to find. Karen researches documentation, in
order to discover lesbian history in the anti-apartheid struggle. An interesting discovery
is that official documentation can reveal more personal information than private letters
or diaries. She plans to increase the lesbian component of the archive, by following clues
to find these 'hidden' lesbians and by recording conversations as part of an oral history
project to keep memories alive. A problem she has encountered is that the majority of
users are white middle class women. She would like to reach out to black women, but
realises that the definition of 'lesbian' that we use comes from a white cultural
background, and also the politics of the ANC support family values, not lesbian values.
Comment:
It is especially important to reach out and include doubly marginalised women, that is for
example, women who are both lesbian and black, who risk being excluded from both
communities.
Lucinda Zoe, Lesbian Herstory Archive, New York
Her paper for this conference will be published at a later date. The lesbian Herstory
Archive was set up in 1973, and has continued to expand and consolidate because of support
and commitment from the lesbian community. They are staffed by volunteers and take no
government money as a matter of principle. They have an international collection policy,
and are open to everyone regardless of why they want to use the collections. They work to
store not only the materials of the lesbian movement, but also the to conserve
time-specific politics while incorporating new ideas.
Recommendations and Resolutions
This page last updated on september 4, 1998. Copyright © 1998 IIAV.
If you have any comments or questions about this page please contact knowhow@iiav.nl